Answers by Patrick Wishart and Alexander Robertson, Writers to the Signet, Trustees of the late Robert Gordon of Craig, to the petition of John Harper in Nether Dalveen, asserting their right to the lands of Craig and Corse under a trust-deed executed by Robert Gordon.
William Tait devises Craig and Corfe lands to trustees William Tait and Thomas Wauch for Margaret’s support and education, with rents to her or her husband, and residual rights to heirs or trustees.
Trustee seeks repayment for tenant’s farm improvements, contested by petitioners who claim repayment only due at lease end and they gained benefit from early possession.
Petitioners challenge an interlocutor holding them liable for Taylor’s creditors’ claim to value of uncompleted buildings, arguing they were not lucrati and entitled to no abatement.
Respondents seek recovery of surplus rent lost after reletting farms post-Taylor’s desertion, arguing creditors can’t claim losses from their business decisions.
Respondents seek to recover losses from reletting lands after Taylor's desertion, including building costs and rent shortfall, while petitioner claims no liability as advocators assumed lease risks.
Advocators seek to establish financial loss or gain from George Taylor’s abandonment of the farm, following prior interlocutor ordering production of lease and transaction records.