Alexander Duff of Echt v. James Brodie of Brodie, Alexander Penrose-Cumming of Altyre, Hugh Grant of Moy, John Gordon of Grievehop, John Innes of Leuchars and Francis Russell of Westfield — Answers, 12 May 1792
May 1792: Esquires Brodie, Cumming, Grant, Gordon, Innes, Russell answer petition of Alexander Duff, asserting prior objections were legally distinct and res judicata inapplicable.