This case was an action for declarator of marriage and legitimacy. Pursuer Katharine Macgregor lived with Lieutenant Duncan Campbell for a number of years prior to his death, and the two had a son. Macgregor initially served as Campbell’s housekeeper, but she alleged that during the year before his death, they traveled to Kinghorn and were married. Macgregor produced depositions from a number of witnesses who testified that people in the couple’s neighborhood commonly believed that they were married. However, the defenders, who were relatives of Lieutenant Campbell, argued that his statements to that effect were unserious, and that Macgregor had not required others—especially Campbell’s servants—to address her as the lady of the house.
People involved
- Katharine Macgregor — Pursuer
- Colin Campbell — Pursuer
- Miss Colin Campbell — Defender
- Patrick Campbell — Defender
- Isabella Campbell — Defender
- Duncan Campbell, Lieutenant — Named in case documents
- John Macgregor — Named in case documents
- William Baillie, Lord Polkemmet — Lord Ordinary
- James Dundas, C.S. — Agent
- H. Clk. — Clerk
- J. Brunton — Agent
- M. Clk. — Clerk
- Edward McCormick — Advocate for Pursuer
- Alexander Murray Drummond, Ensign — Named in case documents
- Mary Robertson — Named in case documents
- Robert Drummond — Named in case documents
- Donald Macintyre — Named in case documents
- Betty Macilwhannel — Named in case documents
- Katharine Macdermaid — Named in case documents
- Grizel Drummond — Named in case documents
- Alexander Macisaac — Named in case documents
- James Macisaac — Named in case documents
- John Drummond — Named in case documents
- Duncan Macgregor — Named in case documents
- John Orr — Named in case documents
- Margaret Macgregor — Named in case documents
- Dr. Peter Comrie — Named in case documents
- James Drummond — Named in case documents
- Isabel Drummond — Named in case documents
- Helen Morison — Named in case documents
- Alexander Comrie — Named in case documents
- Peter Maclaren — Named in case documents
- John Macilwhannel — Named in case documents
- William Macilwhannel — Named in case documents
- Alexander Macarthur — Named in case documents
- Archibald Dewar — Named in case documents
- James Macgregor — Named in case documents
- James Stewart — Named in case documents
- Robert Fergusson — Named in case documents
- John Fergusson — Named in case documents
- Duncan Stewart — Named in case documents
- John Stewart — Named in case documents
- Janet Fergusson — Named in case documents
- William Comrie — Named in case documents
- Janet Stewart — Named in case documents
- John Macilchonnel — Named in case documents
- James Macnab — Named in case documents
- Duncan Campbell — Named in case documents
- Duncan Campbell — Named in case documents
- John Mackay — Named in case documents
- John Drummond — Named in case documents
- Duncan Drummond — Named in case documents
- Hugh Macdiarmid — Named in case documents
- Daniel Ferguson — Named in case documents
Places
- Wester Dundurn (principal)
- Comrie (principal)
This case was an action for declarator of marriage and legitimacy. Pursuer Katharine Macgregor lived with Lieutenant Duncan Campbell for a number of years prior to his death, and the two had a son. Macgregor initially served as Campbell’s housekeeper, but she alleged that during the year before his death, they traveled to Kinghorn and were married. Macgregor produced depositions from a number of witnesses who testified that people in the couple’s neighborhood commonly believed that they were married. However, the defenders, who were relatives of Lieutenant Campbell, argued that his statements to that effect were unserious, and that Macgregor had not required others—especially Campbell’s servants—to address her as the lady of the house.